Miles Brundage outlines five clusters of AI industry participants based on attitudes toward human disempowerment risk
ConcludedRan 4 days2 sourcesupdated 20 Sep 2026
Gradual Disempowerment paper debated; Brundage maps industry attitudes
The gist
The debate turns on whether economic incentives will systematically erode human influence over resources and societal functions as AI replaces humans across nearly all domains. Brundage's taxonomy suggests that a significant portion of the industry does not understand the nature of what they are working on.
When stories like this move, I write about them in an email each morning.
One free email each morning, around 8 AM US Eastern.
Check your email.
I have sent you a confirmation link. One click and you are in.
Not in your inbox? Look in spam or promotions. If it's there, mark it "Not spam" so future editions land in your inbox.
The full picture
Two developments in the AI safety discourse around human disempowerment by AI systems emerged in September 2026. An Alignment Forum author published a rebuttal defending the Kulveit et al. 'Gradual Disempowerment' paper against a critique by Bentham's Bulldog and John Halstead, arguing the critics mischaracterize the paper's core claims. Separately, AI researcher Miles Brundage outlined five clusters of AI industry participants based on how they understand and respond to disempowerment risk, and said clusters two and three, those who oppose disempowerment but rely on solving alignment, and those actively seeking solutions while acknowledging difficulty, are the most influential in the industry.
How it developed
Alignment Forum author publishes rebuttal defending Kulveit et al. 'Gradual Disempowerment' paper against Bentham's Bulldog and John Halstead critique
Sources
Alignment Forum
Miles Brundage on X
- Pachocki, UN Official, Journalist Flag AI Alignment Gaps Publicly
- Nick Cammarata's interpretability reversal
- GPT-5.6 Sol's evaluation and alignment concerns
BackgroundWhen AI doesn't do what we meant
Get the daily email
When stories like this move, I write about them in an email each morning.
One free email each morning, around 8 AM US Eastern.
Check your email.
I have sent you a confirmation link. One click and you are in.
Not in your inbox? Look in spam or promotions. If it's there, mark it "Not spam" so future editions land in your inbox.